It had seemed to me that one absolutely certain fact, beyond all
dispute or question, is that the terror attacks of Sept. 11 had no silver
lining, no unexpectedly beneficial fallout. It was, is and will be a
terrible business with endlessly terrible consequences. It killed thousands,
and impelled a punitive expedition that will almost certainly procreate
further martial forays. The war party is agitating for an onslaught on Iraq,
maybe on North Korea. Here in America, the backwash of Sept. 11 has
shriveled civil liberties and political dissent, and we will spend the rest
of our lives trying to recapture lost ground.
But no. The editor of the Nation, Katrina vanden Heuvel, (whose
periodical has promoted the notion of a "just war" in Afghanistan) has now
coauthored a column with Joel Rogers of the University of Wisconsin/
Madison, published in the Los Angeles Times on Nov. 25, proposing the
following:
"If anything, the war on terrorism creates an opening for
progressives, not closure -- indeed, it presents the opportunity of a
lifetime ... War's mobilization of the populace against a shared threat also