Call it the year of the yellow notepad. Doris Kearns Goodwin,
ejected from Parnassus, from Pulitzer jury service and kindred honorable
obligations, sinks under charges of plagiarism consequent, she claims, upon
sloppy note-taking on her trusty yellow legal pads.
Michael Bellesiles, taking heavy artillery fire for knavish
scholarship in his book "Arming America," says that his notations from
probate records central to his assertions about gun ownership in
eighteenth-century America were on legal yellow pads that were irreparably
damaged when his office at Emory sustained an inundation in 2000, the year
his book was published. Connoisseurs of such sports of nature or of plumbing
may note that, unusually, this particular flood came in May rather than
mid-April, when people have completed their tax returns and are trying to
clean out the Augean stables of their accounting.
Stephen Ambrose, overtaken by charges of plagiarism, did not
have recourse to the yellow-notepad defense, presumably because he had
become rich enough not only to discard them in favor of teams of